3/5 stars on Goodreads
 |
| Shanghai Immortal by A.Y. Chao |
Shanghai Immortal is Asian fantasy set in 1930s Shanghai and its counterpart, Immortal
Shanghai, where the demon king Big Wang rules over ghosts and demons. Lady Jing
is his ward, a half-vampire, half-fox spirit with anger management issues. Her hundredth
birthday is coming up and with that she’ll finally take her place in the
council governing the otherworld. Only, she doesn’t want to.
Neither
does her maternal grandmother, the queen of fox spirits. She failed to kill
Jing when she was a child and she’ll do everything to stop Jing now. But Jing
is onto her plot. If only she could make Big Wang believe her instead of
being sent to the human Shanghai like a rebellious child, with a human man who
owes Big Wang a favour.
This debut novel
was a good try. A good try at fantasy, a good try at historical novel, and a
good try at romance. None of it really worked though, and the result was a mishmash
with a hasty feel and no proper plot.
The Asian
elements didn’t feel entirely Asian, as Jing was such an independent spirit who
didn’t respect anything or anyone, and because the beings of Chinese folklore
were made to behave like ordinary humans with no clues to what they were, Jing’s blood drinking aside. The
historical elements of mortal Shanghai consisted of trivial facts with a lot of
American things in the mix that made them feel inauthentic even if they had
been genuine. And the romance was very unromantic. Partly it was because Mr Lee
was a boring character, but mostly it was because of Jing.
This is
marketed as an adult fantasy and Jing is turning a hundred. But she behaves—and is
being treated—like a sixteen-year-old who’s never seen a man or heard of sex. It wasn’t
cute; it was just aggravating. No matter how sheltered a person has lived, they’ve
learned everything there is to know about human relations and everything else
besides in a century. But Jing showed no signs of a life lived.
Making her behave
like a clueless twit ruined the romance and didn’t do any favours for the book
either. If you want an adult heroine, make her behave like one. Basically, this reads like a young adult fantasy with all the tropes that
go with it, so treat it as such.
I received
a free copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.